An Early Attempt for Public Financial Accountability in Iran: Formation and Failure of the Commission for Implementation of Remittances

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Associate Professor, Department of History, Research Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies, Tehran, I. R. Iran

2 PhD Student of History, Research Institute for Humanities and Cultural Studies, Tehran, I. R. Iran

Abstract

Purpose: To report the performance and the failure of the Commission for the Implementation of Remittances as an early attempt by the Parliament after the 1906 Constitutional Revolution for monitoring public expenditures.
Method and Research Design: Data presented is based on Archival records of the Ministry of Economics and Finance held at the National Archives of Iran and the National Assembly Proceedings.
Findings and Conclusion: The chronic and pervasive corruption in public finance made the members of the newly established parliament of the post-constitutional revolution in 1915 to create a regulatory body – a parliamentary commission- mandated to monitor the expenditure of the public money. The commission was given special power to prevent unlawful expenditures. However, weakness of the government as the result of the occupation of the major parts of the country by Russians, Ottomans, and the British during WWI, incompliance to the commission's rulings by the government departments, limited capacity of the Commission to address all cases, and focusing on minor instead the major cases, ended in the failure of the Commission to fulfill its mission. The commission was dissolved in 1922, replaced by the Financial Supervision Commission.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

English Translation of References
Documents
Ketābxāne, Muze va Markaz-e Asnād-e Majles-e Šorā-ye Eslāmi (Kemām) (Library, Museum and Document Center of Iran Parliament), Retrieval number:
3/169/2/1/18; 3/6/13/1/4; 3/179/11/1/5/21. [Persian]
Sāzmān-e Asnād va Ketābxāne-ye Melli-ye Irān (Sākmā) (National Library and Archives Organization of Iran), Document ID:
          210/002669; 210/9675; 210/2703; 210/9828; 232/2075; 232/2427; 240/ 001961; 240/005397; 240/013047; 240/059441; 240/062775; 240/100816; 240/100817; 240/102421; 240/16202; 240049754; 240/29016; 240/32409; 240/41511; 240/41513; 240/45214; 240/45416; 240/4685; 240/47065; 240/47318; 240/487; 240/509; 240/51751; 240/53481; 240/56235; 240/56236; 240/7014; 240/84648; 295/7258; 295/7390. [Persian]
Books
Afzal Al-Molk, Gholam Hossein. (1361/1982). “Afzal ot-tavārix” (The best of histories). Edited by Mansoureh Ettehadieh & Sirous Saa’dvandian. Tehran: Našr-e Tārix-e Irān. [Persian]
Curzon, George Nathaniel. (1380/2001). “Irān va qazie-ye Irān” (Persia and the Persian question) (vol. 2) (5th ed.). Translated by Gholam Ali Vahid Mazandarani. Tehran: Entešārāt-e ‘Elmi Farhangi. [Persian]
Durand, Henry Mortimer. (1392/2013). “Gozāreš-e Ser Mortimer Dorānd: Asnādi darbāre-ye vaz’eeyat-e Irān dar dahe-ye pāyāni-ye qarn-e nuzdahom” (Sir Mortimer Durand’s report: Documents on Iran in the late nineteenth century). Translated by Ahmad Seif. Tehran: Našr-e Ney. [Persian]
Eyn Al-Saltaneh, Ghahreman Mirza Salour. (1374/1995). “Ruznāme-ye xāterāt-e Eyn os-Saltane” (Journal of Eyn Al-Saltaneh’s memoires) (vol. 2). Edited by Mas’oud Salour & Iraj Afshar. Tehran: Asātir. [Persian]
Farahani, Hassan. (1385/2006). “Ruz-šomār-e tārix-e mo’āser-e Irān” (Chronology of Iranian contemporary history) (vol. 1). Tehran: Mo’assese-ye Motāle’āt va Pažuheš-hā-ye Siāsi (Political Studies and Research Institute). [Persian]
Floor, Willem. (1371/1992). “Tārix-e māli-ye Irān dar ruzegār-e Safaviān va Qājāriān” (A Fiscal history of Iran in the Safavi and Qajar periods 1925 - 1500). Translated by Abu Al-Ghasem Serri. Tehran: Entešārāt-e Tus. [Persian]
Mosaddegh, Mohammad. (1304/1925). “Osul, qavā’ed va qavānin dar mamālek-e xārejeh va Irān” (Principles, regulations and laws in foreign countries and Iran). Tehran: Matba’e-ye Tamaddon. [Persian]
Mosaddegh, Mohammad. (1364/1985). “Xāterāt va ta’ammolāt-e Doktor Mhammad-e Mosaddeq” (Memoirs and reflections of Dr. Mohammad Mossadegh). Edited by Iraj Afshar. Tehran: Mohammad Ali ‘Elmi. [Persian]
Mostowfi, Abdullah. (1388/2009). “Šarh-e zendegāni-ye man, yā tārix-e ejtemā’ee va edāri-ye dowre-ye Qājārieh” (The story of my life, or the social and ministerial history of Qajar era) (vol. 1 & 3). Tehran: Entešārāt-e Zovvār. [Persian]
Navvab Tehrani, Mirza Mahdi. (1376/1997). “Dastur-ol-A’qāb:Resāle-ee enteqādi va siāsi az avāyel-e asr-e Qājār” (Instructions from our ancestors: A critical and political treatise on the early Qajar period). Edited by Seyyed Ali Al Davoud. Tehran: Našr-e Tārix-e Irān. [Persian]
Nezam Al-Saltaneh Mafi, Hossein Gholi. (1362/1983). “Asnād va xāterāt-e Hossein Qoli Xān-e Nezām-os-Saltane-ye Māfi” (Documents and memoirs of Hossein Gholikhan Khan Nizam Al-Saltanah Mafi) (vol. 3) 2nd ed.). edited by Masoumeh Mafi, Mansoureh Ettehadieh, Sirous Saa’dvandian & Hamid Rampisheh. Tehran: Našr-e Tārix-e Irān. [Persian]
Shuster, William Morgan. (1394/2015). “Extenāq-e Irān” (The strangling of Persia: Story of the European diplomacy and oriental intrigue that resulted in the denationalization of twelve million Mohammedans). Translated by Hassan Afshar. Tehran: Našr-e Māhi. [Persian]
Safayi, Ebrahim. (1353/1974). “Zamine-hā-ye ejtemā’ee-ye kudetā-ye 1299” (The social context of the coup in 1299 HS / 1920 AD). Tehran: Šerkat-e Ofset. [Persian]
Watson, Robert Grant. (1340/1961). “Tārix-e Qājār” (The history of Qajar). Translated by Abbas Gholi Azari. (n. p.): n. p. [Persian]
 
Articles
Kiayinejad, Zein Al-Din. (1342/1964). “Divān-e mohāsebāt va qodrat-e qānuni-ye ān” (Supreme Audit Court and its legal power). Kānun-e Vokalā, 88 (Bahman & Esfand 1342 / 1964, February & March), pp. 75-79. [Persian]
Mohammadi, Amin. (1396/2017). “Ketābče-ye mahāsen va ma’āyeb-e divan-e estifā: talāš-e hokumat-e Qājār barā-ye eslāh-e mālieh dar dowre-ye Nāseri” (A booklet on advantages and disadvantages of the Court of Appeal: The efforts of Qajar government for financial improvement in the Nasiri period). Aršiv-e Melli-ye Irān, 3 (2) (1396 Summer / 2017), pp. 136-173. [Persian]
Mohammadi, Amin & Marzieh Samareh Hosseini. (1394/2015). “Barresi-ye barāt va asnād-e šabih-e barāt” (A study of negotiable instrument and similar documents). Payām-e Bahārestān, 8 (26) (Fall & Winter 1394 / 2015, Fall & 2016, Winter), pp. 216-258. [Persian]
“Resāle-ye Majdieh” (Majdieh epistle). (1306/1927). Armaqān, 62 & 63 (Ordibehešt & Xordād 1306/ 1927, May & June), pp. 82-95. [Persian]
Takmil Homayoun, Naser. (1392/2013). “Doktor Mohammad-e Mosaddeq riāsat-e komisiun-e tatbiq-e havale-jāt-e mālieh” (Dr. Mohammad Mossadegh: Chairman of the commission for the implementation of tax expenditures). Boxārā, 15 (95 & 96) (Mehr & Ābān 1392/ 2013, October & November), pp. 177-184. [Persian]
Shahbazi, Kheirollah. (1373/1995). “Seiri dar tahavvolāt-e hoquqi-ye divan-e mohāsebāt az āqāz tā be emruz: Divān-e mohāsebāt dar āyene-ye hoquq” (A look at the legal developments of the Supreme Audit Court from the Beginning to the Present: Supreme Audit Court as reflected in the mirror of Law). Majles va Pažuheš: Majles va Rāhbord (Majlis & Rahbord: Scientific Research Quarterly Journal), 13 (Dey & Bahman 1373/ 1995, January & February), pp. 143-160. [Persian]
Records of parliamentary debates
Mašruh-e mozākerāt-e majles-e Šorā-ye Melli (Detailed records of parliamentary debates of the National Consultative Assembly), 1st term, 1326/1947, vol. 1. [Persian]
Mašruh-e mozākerāt-e majles-e Šorā-ye Melli (Detailed records of parliamentary debates of the National Consultative Assembly), 2nd term, 1328/1949, vol. 134. [Persian]
Mašruh-e mozākerāt-e majles-e Šorā-ye Melli (Detailed records of parliamentary debates of the National Consultative Assembly), 3rd term, 1333/1954, vol. 25. [Persian]
Mašruh-e mozākerāt-e majles-e Šorā-ye Melli (Detailed records of parliamentary debates of the National Consultative Assembly), 3rd term, 1333/1954, vol. 31. [Persian]
Mašruh-e mozākerāt-e majles-e Šorā-ye Melli (Detailed records of parliamentary debates of the National Consultative Assembly), 3rd term, 1333/1954, vol. 47. [Persian]
Mašruh-e mozākerāt-e majles-e Šorā-ye Melli (Detailed records of parliamentary debates of the National Consultative Assembly), 4th term, 1340/1961, vol. 34. [Persian]
Mašruh-e mozākerāt-e majles-e Šorā-ye Melli (Detailed records of parliamentary debates of the National Consultative Assembly), 4th term, 1340/1961, vol. 35. [Persian]
Mašruh-e mozākerāt-e majles-e Šorā-ye Melli (Detailed records of parliamentary debates of the National Consultative Assembly), 4th term, 1340/1961, vol. 36. [Persian]
Mašruh-e mozākerāt-e majles-e Šorā-ye Melli (Detailed records of parliamentary debates of the National Consultative Assembly), 4th term, 1340/1961, vol. 40. [Persian]
Mašruh-e mozākerāt-e majles-e Šorā-ye Melli (Detailed records of parliamentary debates of the National Consultative Assembly), 4th term, 1340/1961, vol. 56. [Persian]
 

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 09 December 2018
  • Revise Date: 13 December 2018
  • Accept Date: 10 March 2019

Share

How to cite

Statistics