Public-Municipality Confrontations over Authoritarian Street Construction in Shiraz during the Pahlavi I Era

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Associate Professor, Department of Urban Planning and Design, School of Art and Architecture, Shiraz University, Shiraz, Iran

2 MA of Urban Design, Faculty of Art, Terbiat Modares University

10.30484/ganj.2024.3200

Abstract

Purpose: This study investigates the process of street construction in Shiraz during the reign of Reza Shah (Pahlavi I), aiming to assess the effects of authoritarian modernization on the city’s social, economic, and cultural structure.
Method and Research Design: Drawing on historical documents, official correspondence, and relevant events, the research analyzes the social consequences of street construction projects and the public’s responses to them.
Findings and Conclusion: The street construction initiatives, carried out under the banner of urban modernization, resulted in the extensive demolition of residential, commercial, and religious structures. These actions provoked widespread dissatisfaction, especially among lower-income groups. The public protests were driven by concerns over violations of property rights, threats to the city’s historical identity, and the erosion of urban cohesion. In some instances, these protests succeeded in limiting the extent of demolition or altering specific project plans.
The street construction projects in Shiraz served as a symbol of imposed modernization, producing not only physical changes but also a profound disconnect between development plans and the community’s actual needs. This study highlights the dynamics of interaction and confrontation between municipal authorities and citizens, shedding light on the multifaceted nature of urban transformation and its impact on Shiraz’s historical identity.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Latin Resources
Book
British minister of the Foreign Office 371, 12293/E3909, Robert Clive reporting on court minister ‘Abd al-Hoseyn Teymurtash, 26 August 1927, Tehran, Iran; see: Iran Political Diaries 1881–1965. (Robert M. Burrell, ed.) [Oxford]: Archive Editions, 1997, vol. 8: 1927–1930, p55.
Fairclough, Norman. (2003). Analysing Discourse: Textual Analysis for Social Research. Routledge.
Forbes, Rosita. (1931). Conflict: Angora to Afghanistan (with a foreword by Brigadier-General Sir Percy Sykes). London: Cassell.
Gaddis, John Lewis. (2002). The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past. Oxford University Press.
Gottdiener, M; Budd, L; Lehtovuori, P. (2015). Key Concepts in Urban Studies. SAGE Publications.
Katouzian, Homa. (1981). The Political Economy of Modern Iran: Despotism and Pseudo-Modernism, 1926–1979. University Press.
McDaniel, Tim. (1991). Autocracy, Modernization, and Revolution in Russia and Iran. Princeton University Press.
Tripp, Herbert Alker. (1950). Road Traffic and its Control. (2nd edn). London: Edward Arnold.
Article
Ahmed, Jashim Uddin. (2010). “Documentary research method: New dimensions”. Indus Journal of Management & Social Science (IJMSS), 4(1), pp 1-14.
Bowen, Glenn A. (2009). “Document analysis as a qualitative research method”. Qualitative research journal, 9(2).
Collection of articles
Cronin, Stephanie. (2004). “The Army, Civil Society and the State in Iran: 1921-1926”. In: Men of Order: Authoritarian Modernization under Atatürk and Reza Shah, 130-63.and Reza Shah. (Atabaki, Touraj; Zürcher, Erik J, Editors). Bloomsbury Publishing.
Engert, H. (1940). “Change in the city of Tehran”. US State Department Archives, Engert Dispatch 1830, 891.101/3, 10 May 1940, Tehran, Iran. In: Majd, Mohammad Gholi. (2012). Great Britain and Reza Shah: The Plunder of Iran, 1921-1941. University Press of Florida.
Grigor, Talinn. (2014). “The king’s white walls Modernism and bourgeois architecture” In: Culture and cultural politics under Reza Shah: The Pahlavi state, new bourgeoisie and the creation of a modern society in Iran. (Devos, Bianca; Werner, Christoph, Editors). Routledge.
Hart, L. (1932). “US State Department Archives”. Dispatch 1393, 891.00/1562, 25 March 1932, 155-56; In: Majd, Mohammad Gholi. (2012). Great Britain and Reza Shah: The Plunder of Iran, 1921-1941. University Press of Florida.
Katouzian, Homa. (2004). “State and Society under Reza Shah” In: Men of order: authoritarian modernization under Atatürk and Reza Shah. (Atabaki, Touraj; Zürcher, Erik J, Editors). Bloomsbury Publishing.
Safamanesh, Kamran. (2009). “Architectural Historiography 1921–1942”. In: Iran in the 20th century: Historiography and political culture. (Touraj Atabaki, Editor). London: I. B. Tauris.
 
English Translation of References
Archival Documents
Aks-e havāyi-ye sāl-e 1335 SH Širāz” (Aerial photo of Shiraz in 1956). Tehran: Sāzmān-e Naqše-bardāri-ye Kešvari (Iran National Cartographic Center). [In Persian]
Naqše-ye Šahr-e Širāz” (Map of the city of Shiraz). (1302/1923). Firouz Mirza Nosrat al-Dowleh supervised by Mirza Abolhasan Khan Mohandes. [In Persian]
Naqše-ye Širāz” (Map of Shiraz). (1326/1947). Drawn by Sarhang Ghavanlou & Sheibani. [In Persian]
Naqše-ye Širāz” (Map of Shiraz). (1328/1949). Drawn by Alireza Fadakar. [In Persian]
Qānun-e rāje’ be ehdās va towse’e-ye ma’āber va xiyābān-hā” (Law on the construction and development of streets and passages). (Passed on 22 Ābān 1312 SH / 13 November 1933 AD). Tehran: Matba’e-ye Novin. [In Persian]
Sāzmān-e Asnād va Ketābxāne-ye Melli-ye Irān (Sākmā) (National Library and Archives Organization of Iran):
220/18257/25; 240/36971/4; 293/6090; 293/18007/35; 293/38830; 293/38877; 350/347/51; 350/347/85; 350/347/86; 350/347/105; 350/347/106; 350/347/107; 350/5594/1; 350/7414/1; 350/7414/2; 350/7414/4; 350/7414/5; 350/7414/10; 350/7414/11; 350/7414/12; 350/7414/13; 350/7414/15; 350/7414/17; 350/7414/19; 350/7414/20; 350/7414/21; 350/7414/22; 350/7414/24; 350/7414/25; 350/7414/26; 350/7414/28; 350/7414/29; 350/7414/32; 350/7414/33; 350/7414/35; 350/7414/36; 350/7414/37. [In Persian]
Books
Abrahamian, Ervand. (1377/1998). “Irān bein-e do enqelāb” (Iran between two revolutions). Translated by Ahmad Golmohammadi & Mohammad Ebrahim Fattahi. Tehran: Ney. [In Persian]
Adamiat, Fereidoun. (1352/1973). “Andiše-ye taraqqi va hokumat-e qānun-e ‘asr-e sepah-sālār” (The idea of progress and the rule of law: The Era of Sepahsalar). Tehran: Xārazmi. [In Persian]
Afsar, Karamatollah. (1353/1974). “Tārix-e bāft-e qadimi-ye Širāz” (History of the old texture of Shiraz). Tehran: Anjoman-e Āsār-e Melli (Society for the National Heritage of Iran). [In Persian]
Ajoudani, Mashallah. (1382/2003). “Mašrute-ye Irāni” (The Iranian Constitution). Tehran: Axtarān. [In Persian]
Aryanpour, Alireza. (1365/1986). “Pažuheši dar šenāxt-e bāq-hā-ye Irān va bāq-hā-ye tārixi-ye Širāz” (A general survey of Persian gardens and an investigation of the historical gardens of Shiraz). Tehran: Farhangsarā (Yasāvoli). [In Persian]
British minister of the Foreign Office 371, 12293/E3909, Robert Clive reporting on court minister ‘Abd al-Hoseyn Teymurtash, 26 August 1927, Tehran, Iran; see: Iran Political Diaries 1881–1965. (Robert M. Burrell, ed.) [Oxford]: Archive Editions, 1997, vol. 8: 1927–1930, p55.
Dehkhoda, Ali Akbar. (1377/1998). “Loqat-nāme” (Dehkhoda lexicon) (vol. 7). Tehran: Mo’assese-ye Loqat-nāme-ye Dehxodā (Dehkhoda Dictionary Institute). [In Persian]
Ejlali, Farzam. (1373/1994). “Bonyān-e hokumat-e Qājār: Nezām-e siāsi-ye ili va divan-sālāri-ye modern” (The foundation of the Qajar government: Tribal political system and modern bureaucracy). Tehran: Našr-e Ney. [In Persian]
Fairclough, Norman. (2003). Analyzing discourse: Textual analysis for social research. Routledge.
Forbes, Rosita. (1931). Conflict: Angora to Afghanistan (with a foreword by Brigadier-General Sir Percy Sykes). London: Cassell.
Gaddis, John Lewis. (2002). The Landscape of History: How Historians Map the Past. Oxford University Press.
Ghasem Khan, Alireza. (1397/2018). “Tekye-ye dowlat: Az budan va nabudan” (The reliance of the state: On being and not being). Tehran: ‘Elmi Farhangi. [In Persian]
Golestan, Ebrahim. (1348/1969). “Madd-o meh: Se dāstān” (Tide and mist). Tehran: Rowzan. [In Persian]
Gottdiener, M; & Budd, L; Lehtovuori, P. (2015). Key Concepts in Urban Studies. SAGE Publications.
Habibi, Seyyed Mohsen. (1378/1999). “Az šār tā šahr” (From the stream to the city). Tehran: Dānešgāh-e Tehrān (University of Tehran). [In Persian]
Habibi, Seyyed Mohsen. (1384/2005). “Az šār tā šahr” (From the stream to the city). Tehran: Dānešgāh-e Tehrān (University of Tehran). [In Persian]
Hosseini Fasaei, Haj Mirza Hasan. (1378/1999). “Fārs-nāme-ye Nāseri” (Naseri’s book on Fars) (vols. 1 & 2). Edited and annotated by Mansour Rastegar Fasaei. Tehran: Amir Kabir. [In Persian]
Jafarian, Rasoul. (1385/2006). “Dark-e šahri az mašruteh: Moqāyese-ye hoze-ye mašrute-xāhi-ye Esfahān va Tabriz” (Urban understanding of the constitutionalism: A comparison of the constitutionalist spheres of Isfahan and Tabriz). Tehran: Mo’assese-ye Motāle’āt-e Tārix-e Mo’āser-e Irān (Institute for Iranian Contemporary Historical Studies) (IICHS). [In Persian]
Kamrava, Mohammad Ali. (1384/2005). “Moqaddame-ee bar šahrsāzi-ye mo’āser-e Irān” (An introduction to contemporary urbanism in Iran). Tehran: Dānešgāh-e Tehrān (University of Tehran). [In Persian]
Kariman, Hossein. (1355/1976). “Tehrān dar gozašteh va hāl” (Tehran in the past and present). Tehran: Entešārāt-e Dānešgāh-e Melli-ye Irān. [In Persian]
Katouzian, Homa. (1981). The Political Economy of Modern Iran: Despotism and Pseudo-Modernism, 1926–1979. University Press.
Kiani, Mostafa. (1383/2004). “Me’māri-ye dowre-ye Pahlavi-ye avval” (Architecture of the first Pahlavi period). Tehran: Mo’assese-ye Motāle’āt-e Tārix-e Mo’āser-e Irān (Institute for Iranian Contemporary Historical Studies) (IICHS). [In Persian]
Ketābxāneh, Muzeh, va Markaz-e Asnād-e Ketābxāne-ye Majles-e Šorā-ye Eslāmi (Library, Museum and Document Center of parliament). [In Persian]
Khalesi, Mohammadreza. (1387/2008). “Az baladiye tā šahrdāri: Tārix-e sad-sāle-ye šahrdāri-ye Širāz” (From the city council to the municipality: A hundred-year history of Shiraz). Širāz: Šahrdāri-ye Širāz (Shiraz Municipality). [In Persian]
Khalilikhou, Mohammadreza. (1373/1994). “Towse’e va nosāzi-ye Irān dar dore-ye Rezā Šāh” (Development and modernization of Iran during the reign of Reza Shah). Tehran: Jahād-e Dānešgāhi-ye Vāhed-e Šahid Behešti (Academic Development of the Shahid Beheshti University). [In Persian]
McDaniel, Tim. (1991). Autocracy, modernization, and revolution in Russia and Iran. Princeton University Press.
Mirsepasi, Ali. (1384/2005). “Ta’ammoli dar modernite-ye Irāni: Bahsi darbāre-ye goftemān-hā-ye rowšan-fekri va siyāsat-e modernizāsiyun dar Irān” (Negotiating modernity in Iran: Intellectual discourse and the politics of modernization). Translated by Jalal Tavakkolian. Tehran: Tarh-e no. [In Persian]
Mokhber Al-Saltaneh Hedayat, Mahdi Gholi. (1344/1965). “Xāterāt va xatarāt: Tuš-ee az tārix-e šeš pādešāh, va guše-ee az dowre-ye zendegi-ye man” (Memories and Dangers) (2nd ed.). Tehran: Ketābforuši-ye Zovvār. [In Persian]
Nadim, Mostafa. (1394/2015). “Xiyābān-e Karim Xān-e Zand-e Širāz (Hamrāh bā barresi-ye tārixi, ejtemā’ee-ye mahalle-ye pošt-e ostāndāri)” (Karim Khan Zand Street, Shiraz (with a historical and social survey of the neighborhood behind the governorate)). Širāz: Omid-e Dānā. [In Persian]
Nayyer Shirazi, Abd al-Rasoul; Nayyeri, Mohammad Yousef; & Niazkar, Farah. (1387/2008). “Ruzgār-e Pahlavi-ye avval: Naqd va tahlil-e roxdād-hā-ye mohem-me siyāsi, farhangi va ejtemā’ee rad ruzgār-e Rezā Šāh hamrāh bā nokte-hā va sargozašt-hā-ye ‘ebrat-āmuz” (The First Pahlavi Era: Criticism and analysis of important political, cultural, and social events in the era of Reza Shah). Širāz: Daryā-ye Nur. [In Persian]
Raeesi, Akbar. (1388/2009). “Gozari bar ravand-e tahavvolāt va taškilāt-e šahrdāri-ye Širāz az ehtesābieh tākonun” (A review of the developments and organization of Shiraz Municipality from its establishment to the present). Širāz: Šahrdāri-ye Širāz (Shiraz Municipality). [In Persian]
Sane’, Mansour. (1369/1990). “Peydāyeš-e ‘akkāsi dar Širāz” (The emergence of photography in Shiraz). Tehran: Soruš. [In Persian]
Sane’, Mansour. (1380/2001). “Be yād-e Širāz: ‘Aks-hā-ye Širāz-e qadim” (In memory of Shiraz: Photos of old Shiraz). Tehran: Mansur Sāne’. [In Persian]
Sane’, Mansour. (1390/2011). “Širāz-e kudaki-ye mā: ‘Aks-hā-ye Širāz-e qadim” (Our childhood Shiraz: Photographs of old Shiraz). Širāz: Mansur Sāne’. [In Persian]
Sane’, Mansour. (1396/2017). “Širāz-e ruzgār-e javāni: ‘Aks-hā-ye Širāz-e qadim” (Shiraz: the days of youth). Tehran: Mansur Sāne’. [In Persian]
Takmil Homayoun, Naser. (1378/1999). “Tārix-e ejtemā’ee va farhangi-ye Tehrān” (Social and cultural history of Tehran) (vol. 2). Tehran: Dafter-e Pažuheš-hā-ye Farhangi. [In Persian]
Tripp, Herbert Alker. (1950). Road traffic and its control. (2nd ed.). London: Edward Arnold.
Zoka, Yahya. (1349/1970). “Tārixče-ye sāxtemān-hā-ye arg-e saltanati-ye Tehrān va rāhnamā-ye Kāx-e Golestān” (History of the buildings of the Royal Citadel of Tehran and a guide to the Golestan Palace). Tehran: Anjoman-e Āsār-e Melli (Society for the National Heritage of Iran). [In Persian]
Articles
Ahmed, Jashim Uddin. (2010). “Documentary research method: New dimensions”. Indus Journal of Management & Social Science (IJMSS), 4(1), pp 1-14.
Bowen, Glenn A. (2009). “Document analysis as a qualitative research method”. Qualitative research journal, 9(2).
Esmaeeldokht, Maryam. (1396/2017). “Qiyās-e tatbiqi-ye xāneš-e sākenin az šahr (manzar-e šahri) bā tarh-hā-ye towse’e-ye šahri-ye barresi-ye enteqāl-e manzar-e šahr-e sonnati be šahr-e mo’āser-e Širāz” (The study of the dominant interventions (beliefs) on the aesthetics of Zand Street in Shiraz in three periods of history). Bāq-e Nazar (Bagh-e Nazar), 18(96), pp. 45-58. [In Persian]
Esmaeeldokht, Maryam; Mansouri, Seyyed Amir; & Sheibani, Mehdi. (1400/2021). “Modāxelāt-e didgāh-e hākem bar zibāyi-šenāsi-ye xiyābān-e Zand-e Širāz dar se dowre-ye tārixi” (A comparative study of citizens’ interpretations of the city (urban landscape) and urban development plans a transition from a traditional landscape to a modern one in Shiraz). Honar va Tamaddon-e Šarq (Journal of Art and Civilization of the Orient) (JACO), 5(18), pp. 43-54. [In Persian]
Khoddami, Mehdi; Nouraei, Morteza; & Foroughi Abri, Asghar. (1397/2018). “Barresi-ye ‘amalkard-e baladiyeh dar dowre-ye Pahlavi-ye avval; Nemune-pažuhi: Širāz” (An analytical study on the performance of small Baladias during Reza Shah’s era; Case study of Fars). Pažuheš-hā-ye Tārixi (Research Journal of Iran Local Histories), 10(39), pp. 1-23. [In Persian]
Sheibani, Mehdi; Parvin, Hossein; & Farnoush, Fahimeh. (1396/2017). “Šahr-bāq, sāxtvr-e šahri-ye Širāz-e qadim” (Garden City, an examination of the old urban structure of Shiraz). Honar va Tamaddon-e Šarq (Journal of Art and Civilization of the Orient) (JACO), 5(16), pp. 33-40. [In Persian]
Collection of articles
Cronin, Stephanie. (2004). “The Army, Civil Society and the State in Iran: 1921-1926”. In: Men of Order: Authoritarian Modernization under Atatürk and Reza Shah, 130-63.and Reza Shah. (Atabaki, Touraj; Zürcher, Erik J, Editors). Bloomsbury Publishing.
Engert, H. (1940). “Change in the city of Tehran”. US State Department Archives, Engert Dispatch 1830, 891.101/3, 10 May 1940, Tehran, Iran. In: Majd, Mohammad Gholi. (2012). Great Britain and Reza Shah: The Plunder of Iran, 1921-1941. University Press of Florida.
Grigor, Talinn. (2014). “The king’s white walls Modernism and bourgeois architecture” In: Culture and cultural politics under Reza Shah: The Pahlavi state, new bourgeoisie and the creation of a modern society in Iran. (Devos, Bianca; Werner, Christoph, Editors). Routledge.
Habibi, Mohsen. (1375/1996). “Tahavvol va Gostareš-e Tehrān dar zaman-e Rezā Šāh” (The evolution and expansion of Tehran during the time of Reza Shah). In Shahriar Adl et al., Sāzmān-e Mošāver-e Fanni va Mohandesi-ye šahr-e Tehrān (Emco Iran Consulting Engineers), Anjoman-e Irān-šenāsi-ye Farānseh dar Irān (Institut Français de Recherche en Iran) (Eds.), “Tehrān pāytaxt-e devist-sāleh (Majmu’e- maqālāt)” (Tehran, the Two-hundred-year capital (Collection of articles)) (pp. 221-229). Tehran: Irān-šenāsi (Encyclopedia of Iranian Studies). [In Persian]
Hart, L. (1932). “US State Department Archives”. Dispatch 1393, 891.00/1562, 25 March 1932, 155-56; In: Majd, Mohammad Gholi. (2012). Great Britain and Reza Shah: The Plunder of Iran, 1921-1941. University Press of Florida.
Katouzian, Homa. (2004). “State and Society under Reza Shah” In: Men of order: authoritarian modernization under Atatürk and Reza Shah. (Atabaki, Touraj; Zürcher, Erik J, Editors). Bloomsbury Publishing.
Safamanesh, Kamran. (2009). “Architectural Historiography 1921–1942”. In: Iran in the 20th century: Historiography and political culture. (Touraj Atabaki, Editor). London: I. B. Tauris.
Press
Ruznāme-ye Estaxr (Estakhr newspaper), issue 35, 18 Dey 1303 SH / 8 January 1925 AD. [In Persian]
Ruznāme-ye Fārs (Fars newspaper), issue 17, 5 Dey 1298 SH / 27 December 1919 AD. [In Persian]
Ruznāme-ye Golestān (Golestan newspaper) (Special issue) (), issue 35, 4 Mehr 1298 SH / 27 September 1919 AD. [In Persian]
Ruznāme-ye Golestān (Golestan newspaper), issue 745, 6 Šahrivar 1310 SH / 29 August 1931 AD. [In Persian]
Ruznāme-ye Vaqāye’ (Vaqaye-e Ettefaqiyeh), issue 1, 18 Āzar 1304 SH / 9 December 1925 AD. [In Persian]
Ruznāme-ye Xoršid-e Irān (Khorshid-e Iran newspaper), issue 1, 27 Bahman 1302 SH / 17 February 1924 AD. [In Persian]